Last August or so I took up a somewhat unconventional argument that it was vastly more important for Miguel Cabrera to win the Triple Crown than the puny MVP award. Sure, at the time, one (TC) might ensure the other (MVP), and it did, but for the purpose of building a untouchable historical legacy, I argued that a Triple Crown makes you a baseball immortal. An MVP does not.
Aside from Joe Medwick, who was no slouch with a career .324 average, every TC winner since 1900 is essentially an MLB legend. Here they are.
Sure, some of baseball's titans have won MVPs (full list here), but so have Bobby Shantz, Willie McGee, Elston Howard and other names you're unfamiliar with. And that's not to slight Cabrera; he's now IN the argument with Pujols for best player over the last decade, and as @CrashburnAlley said on Twitter over the weekend, Cabrera's BR page is truly baseball porn.
This year, with there already being discussion about not only back to back MVP campaigns for Cabrera - I'll bet on that - but back to back TC years as well.
Think about that. No one a TC in 40+ years, and now the SAME guy might do it two years in a row.
Miguel Cabrera is so supreme a hitter right now that your immediate response to the thought of back to back TC's wasn't 'I need to stop drinking.' Back to back TC's for Cabrera is something very viable.
Which brings me to something I'd prefer over even such a transcendental achievement.
I'd like Cabrera to approach the top ten on this list of all time RBI seasons.
I know, I know, back to back TC's would put Cabrera in a seemingly unreachable universe, but if at some point Chris Davis goes on multiple homerun binges leaving him with more than Cabrera, or if Robinson Cano, in a contract year, snatches the batting crown away from Miggy it would be quite a piece of history in its own right if Cabrera's RBI total topped the number I have in mind.
It's not Hack Wilson's 191 or Gehrig's 184.
Even with Cabrera streaking toward a historic 194 at this point, pace and projections, even with an omnipotent force like the reigning AL MVP, are just fun numbers to daydream about early in the year. There's always slumps and regressions. I'll wager more that Cabrera wins a second TC, before I put money on him keeping this unthinkable RBI pace.
So what's my magic digit for Cabrera?
166. Though I may settle for 149 or 150.
165 is how many Manny Ramirez drove in during his '99 campaign. The other names in that area on the list are Foxx, DiMaggio, Ruth and a few others. They were good. A lot good.
If Torii Hunter, Austin Jackson, and even Omar Infante in the 9 hole continue to provide Cabrera with plenty of runners on base, 166 is definitely a manageable goal.
But, if Hunter tumbles back to earth and Infante reverts to a more typical bottom of the order hitter (instead of a 2-hole type producer), 166 may be unreachable for Cabrera.
However, let's assume drug testing has lessened the cheaters in the game and pitching has reasserted itself as the decisive side of the game, then let's remove all the Steroid Era players from the single season RBI list.
That's fair, no?
Goodbye to Alex Rodriguez, Manny, Juan Gonzalez, Sammy Sosa, Andres Galaragga, Miguel Tejada, Albert Belle and sorry to convict you, but as part of the era, Ryan Howard's 149 are nudged aside.
If you can agree to remove all of those enhanced, and those suspected to have done just that (OK, leave Howard), equaling or best George Foster's 149 RBIs in 1977 would once again land Cabrera is historical prestigous company. Sure there's names like Ken Williams and Tommy Davis (who!?) on the all tiem RBI list, but for the most part that list is littered with the very best hitters who've ever picked up a bat for a Major League team.
Ruth, Gehrig, Greenberg, Foxx, Cabrera.
It doesn't look like it fits...now. But as the present becomes the past, and the history, Cabrera's name may fit just fine amid those names above.





